This week our faculty listening group met to talk through Season 1: Episodes 3 and 4 of Emily Hanford’s Sold a Story. If you missed the start of this series, Part 1 explains how we set it up and what the first two episodes taught us about the difference between looking like a reader and actually reading.
The rhythm is the same. Each of us listens to about an hour of the podcast, responds to a prompt in our online class space, reads and replies to colleagues, and then we meet in person. The ones doing the talking are the ones learning, and this group has been talking a lot.
If Part 1 was about what was going wrong for children, Episodes 3 and 4 asked a harder question: why did it keep going wrong, even after the research was clear? And what do we want to hold on to as we change?

Evidence doesn’t walk into classrooms on its own
Episode 3 tells the story of Reading First, the federal effort in the early 2000s to put reading research into schools, and the resistance it met. Hanford describes a field where research and practice ran on separate tracks.
Our prompt asked: Why do you think evidence had so much trouble getting into classrooms?
Our colleagues named the barriers with real clarity, and with real honesty about themselves.
- The messenger. Several colleagues said plainly that politics shaped what they were willing to hear. One wrote that she distrusted the agenda behind No Child Left Behind and questioned whether it would serve the students she taught at the time. In the episode, one teacher realized she had rejected the source before she ever weighed the research.
- Trusted experts saying not to trust the science. In a 2005 speech, Gay Su Pinnell told a room full of educators, “We cannot count on science.” When someone you admire says that, it’s easy to stop listening. One colleague noticed that a teacher in the episode never looked into the research at all, because she assumed Fountas and Pinnell were the experts. That isn’t carelessness. It’s what most of us do when our professors and colleagues all point in the same direction.
- Time and preparation. One teacher pointed out that curriculum decisions are often made far from classrooms, and that most teachers simply don’t have time to dig into research during a busy week. Another colleague noted that teacher preparation focused far more on literature and classroom management than on how the brain learns to read, so intuition and district-purchased materials filled the gap.
- Feelings. A world language teacher summed it up in four words: “Resistance is a feeling.” When a change lands as criticism of how we’ve been doing our jobs, big feelings make complete sense. As another colleague put it, nobody likes being told they are wrong.
It’s a lot easier to love reading when you know how
Episode 4 takes seriously why so many teachers loved Lucy Calkins’ Units of Study: the joy, the choice, the community of readers. It also names what was missing.
Our prompt asked: Which of those values do you want to keep, and how could they live alongside explicit decoding instruction?
Nobody wanted to give up joy, choice, or community. What shifted was the order. Lacey Robinson’s words landed for many of us. Not everyone has to love reading and writing, she said, but everyone has a right to learn to do them. “I want them to know how to do it. Love comes later.” Zoe showed us that order back in Episode 1. She didn’t love reading when she was guessing. She called it “the best thing ever” once she could actually decode the words.
Colleagues found beautiful ways to describe what the foundation does:
- A world language teacher described decoding as the skeletal system of the reader: without it, readers “cannot breathe in the beauty of literature.” You don’t see the skeleton when you admire a dancer, but nothing moves without it.
- A teacher who chose community as the value to keep framed reading as communication. She was moved by Lacey Robinson’s grandmother, who wanted to learn to read her Bible. Holding a book can give a child a taste of belonging. Decoding gives them a community they can actively participate in. She also asked the question that echoes Part 1: when a kindergartner is asked to read a book of choice for 30 to 45 minutes before they can decode, what exactly are they doing during that time?
- Several colleagues described Trinity as a place where joyful learning has intentionality and purpose. Research-based approaches set the foundation, and teachers’ professional judgment brings the joy and authenticity. Structure and autonomy can live together.
- Practical bridges came up, too: small groups and book clubs where children talk about books as a community while practicing the exact skills those books require, and rich read-alouds that let our youngest learners enjoy stories they can’t yet decode.
Feels good to teach, or helps every child learn?
A world language teacher shared a video of students reading a chapter in Spanish, a language neither of them speaks at home. Their reading isn’t perfect, and it’s impressive. She also wrote a sentence that could anchor this whole series: sometimes students are having fun and participating, but that doesn’t necessarily mean everyone understands.
That’s the distinction I keep returning to. A lively, joyful lesson can feel like success. The check that matters is whether the children who are struggling can apply what they’ve learned.
She offered advice for new teachers, too: not every strategy works for every child. I agree that we have to know our students. What this series suggests is that the amount and intensity of instruction varies while the foundation stays the same. Reid Lyon estimated that about 60% of children need explicit, direct instruction to learn to read, and some need a lot of it. So we adjust how much and how often, while keeping the core skills for everyone. Learning is the constant; time is the variable.
What’s our version in math?
As a former math teacher, I can’t listen to these episodes without asking what our versions are. Math education has its own celebrities, its own beautifully packaged programs, and its own debates where research and practice run on separate tracks. At Trinity, we love Illustrative Math and Building Thinking Classrooms. However, we are not an IM or a BTC school. That’s exactly why this episode is a good mirror for me. What evidence would tell us it’s working for every child, not just the ones who already see themselves as mathematicians? At Trinity, we know that one strategy, one program, one approach will not reach every child. We use a variety of materials and teach multiple strategies to reach more students. We commit to a system of checks and balances for foundational skills and hold ourselves accountable to assess during benchmark periods and take action on behalf of students who have not yet achieved.
What’s next
In December we’ll take on Episodes 5 and 6, where the story turns to publishers, universities, and the question one colleague asked this week: why did so many smart, caring educators keep ignoring the research? I suspect it will push us even further.
Until then, I’ll leave you with the question I’ve been asking myself:
What helps you stay a learner, rather than a fan, of the work you believe in?